How can the Sense Maker help in VUCA environments and the use of metaphors?
SenseMaker is highly effective in VUCA environments, especially when it comes to using metaphors to capture complex and often implicit insights.
What is VUCA?
VUCA is an acronym that describes the challenging conditions and characteristics of complex, rapidly changing environments. It stands for:
Volatility – The nature and dynamics of change, which are unpredictable and fast-moving
Uncertainty – The lack of clarity and predictability about the future, making it difficult to plan accurately
Complexity – The multiple interconnected parts and variables that are often hard to understand and manage
Ambiguity – The lack of clarity and potential for misinterpretation, with situations open to multiple interpretations
VUCA environments are common and especially in politics. Recent experiences in Europe highlight how VUCA conditions manifest in complex political landscapes:
Volatility – The Migrant Crisis and Border Control
The migrant crisis in Europe, particularly the surges in migration from regions experiencing conflict and instability (such as Syria, Afghanistan, and North Africa), exemplifies volatility. The volume and movement of people can change rapidly based on new crises or conflicts, creating unpredictable pressures on border control, infrastructure, and social services. European countries are often required to respond immediately, without much time for long-term planning, as seen in the sudden influx of refugees during crises.
Uncertainty – Brexit and Economic Relations
Brexit is a prime example of uncertainty in Europe. The UK's departure from the EU introduced years of economic, legal, and political uncertainty for both the UK and EU member states. Negotiations on trade, citizen rights, and regulatory alignment faced repeated delays, and even years later, there is continued uncertainty over certain elements of the UK-EU relationship. This ongoing lack of clarity complicates decision-making for businesses, investors, and government policies.
Complexity – The European Green Deal and Climate Goals
The European Green Deal, aimed at making Europe climate-neutral by 2050, represents a highly complex endeavor. It involves coordination among multiple stakeholders—countries, industries, NGOs, and the public—each with different priorities, levels of development, and regulatory frameworks. The interconnectedness of policies on emissions, renewable energy, agricultural practices, and economic restructuring creates a complex environment requiring sophisticated, cross-border cooperation.
Ambiguity – NATO and Security Policies in the EU
Ambiguity in European politics is visible in the domain of security and defense, especially around NATO's role and European autonomy. The ambiguity arises from the differing interpretations and priorities of member states regarding collective defense, European “strategic autonomy,” and how to handle security threats independently from the U.S. While some countries see NATO as indispensable, others are advocating for a more unified European defense strategy. This ambiguity complicates both policy and alliances, leading to varied and often conflicting expectations among member states.
What does that mean for our European future?
The recent election of Donald Trump as the new U.S. President introduces additional layers of VUCA for Europe, influencing various political, economic, and security dynamics:
Volatility – Instability in Transatlantic Relations
During Trump’s previous term, transatlantic relations were marked by frequent policy shifts, especially in areas like trade, NATO commitments, and global alliances. His approach often involved sudden announcements, such as increased tariffs on European goods or questioning the value of NATO. If he were to return, Europe could face renewed volatility in its relationship with the U.S., with the potential for rapid, unanticipated shifts in trade, defense commitments, or diplomatic alliances, which would affect Europe’s stability and economic forecasts.
Uncertainty – Doubts About NATO and Collective Security
Trump's critical stance on NATO funding and his emphasis on "America First" raised concerns about the U.S.'s commitment to the alliance. In a VUCA framework, Trump’s return might introduce new uncertainties about the U.S. commitment to defending Europe in the event of security threats, particularly relevant given rising tensions with Russia and other global security challenges. This uncertainty could force European nations to reconsider their own security strategies and potentially accelerate initiatives toward European defense autonomy, a move that would carry its own set of uncertainties.
Complexity – Economic and Trade Policy Challenges
Trump’s approach to trade often involved unilateral tariffs and a preference for bilateral agreements, challenging the established norms of multilateral trade with Europe. A Trump presidency would likely complicate the EU’s trade policy, potentially involving new tariffs, renegotiated deals, or even economic sanctions if Europe’s policies don’t align with U.S. interests. Europe’s complex trade network, which includes relationships with China, Russia, and other global players, could become even more intricate as leaders navigate Trump’s preference for deal-making over broader, consistent trade policies.
Ambiguity – Shifting U.S. Position on Global Issues
Under Trump, the U.S. position on issues such as climate change, international agreements (like the Paris Agreement), and multilateral organizations (e.g., the UN and WHO) became unpredictable. This ambiguity would affect Europe’s role in global governance, as it might lead the EU to step into a leadership role in certain areas while simultaneously trying to anticipate and adapt to the U.S.’s potentially contradictory stances. The lack of clarity around American support on issues like climate action, human rights, or sanctions could create ambiguous situations where Europe is left to interpret U.S. intentions or act independently without clear signals from a key ally.
A Trump presidency
could heighten Europe’s experience of a VUCA environment, challenging European leaders to adopt flexible, resilient, and independent strategies to ensure stability, security, and progress on the continent.
Here’s how SenseMaker can support decision and policy making in Europe in a VUCA environment:
Capturing Diverse Perspectives with Metaphors
In VUCA contexts, people's experiences and viewpoints are diverse and nuanced, often requiring tools that go beyond traditional surveys or metrics. SenseMaker allows participants to share experiences and perceptions through storytelling and metaphors, which help convey deeper meanings that are not easily captured through direct questions.
For example, instead of asking, "How do you feel about the current strategy?" SenseMaker might prompt with a metaphor, like "If this strategy were an animal, what kind would it be?" The responses to these kinds of questions reveal underlying attitudes, emotions, and interpretations that people might otherwise struggle to articulate.
Making Sense of Complexity through Self-Signification
Self-signification, a core feature of SenseMaker, allows individuals to interpret their own stories by selecting tags or placing them on a triad. This method empowers participants to draw connections between their experiences and abstract ideas like volatility or ambiguity. Using metaphors, participants can classify their stories in a way that aligns with the complexity of VUCA environments, which might be challenging to achieve through conventional data-gathering methods.
For instance, if a citizen describes their experience as a “roller coaster,” they can map their story to emotions like excitement, fear, or unpredictability, providing policy makers with a nuanced view of political dynamics.
Identifying Patterns and Emerging Themes
SenseMaker excels at aggregating and analyzing large volumes of metaphor-laden data, helping politicians identify common themes and emerging patterns across diverse perspectives. By analyzing how frequently specific metaphors (like "sailing through a storm" for instability or "a puzzle with missing pieces" for ambiguity) appear, leaders can pinpoint prevalent concerns or mindsets that might otherwise remain hidden.
Facilitating Strategic Adjustments
Once common metaphors and themes are identified, SenseMaker data can guide strategic decisions, helping leaders adapt more agilely. For instance, if many citizens view their roles as a "battle" in a complex environment, this insight might suggest a need for better support or collaboration.
SenseMaker leverages storytelling and metaphor to surface insights from complex, VUCA environments, making it an invaluable tool for gathering hard-to-reach perceptions and adapting strategies to meet emergent needs.
Do you want to use our SenseMaker for better understanding of your community?
Contact us and we can help.
